⏱️ Estimated reading time: 7 minutes
Choosing the Right Label: Paper or Waterproof?
Ever found yourself stuck picking the right label for your products? You’re not alone. Labels might seem straightforward, but the choice between paper and waterproof materials can really affect how your brand looks and performs.
Let’s break down when it makes sense to go with paper labels and when waterproof ones are worth the extra investment. Along the way, we’ll share tips and real-world examples to help you get it spot on.
⏱️ Reading time: 7 minutes · Updated for 2025 · UK Printing Guide
Why Label Material Matters More Than You Think
Labels aren’t just about slapping a name on a product; they’re often the very first impression your customers get. That means the durability, finish, and even the feel of the label can sway perceptions more than you might expect. Picking the right material isn’t just a practical choice—it can save you from headaches like peeling, fading, or unhappy customers down the line.
Paper Labels: The Classic Choice
Paper labels have long been the go-to for many businesses, especially when products are designed for indoor use and won’t be exposed to moisture or rough handling. They’re generally cheaper and print beautifully, offering a tactile, natural feel that can add a subtle layer of authenticity to your packaging. For instance, uncoated or recycled paper options can lend a soft, matte finish that feels warm and approachable—qualities that some brands crave.
Many clients we work with choose paper labels for dry food packaging like cereals or artisanal crackers, gift boxes, or promotional materials where a touch of elegance and eco-friendliness matters. Plus, paper labels have the added advantage of being easier to write on by hand if you need to jot down batch numbers or personal messages. This is why small-batch producers or craft brands often lean towards paper despite the availability of more high-tech alternatives.
Waterproof Labels: Built to Last
Flip the coin, and waterproof labels come into their own when products face exposure to moisture, oils, or varying temperatures. Think about cosmetics that might get splashed in the bathroom, bottles stored in refrigerators, or household cleaning products that will inevitably encounter wet hands. In these situations, paper labels can quickly become damaged, smudged, or peel off entirely.
Waterproof labels are typically made from synthetic materials such as polypropylene or vinyl, which can be finished in glossy or matte styles. These materials are great at resisting smudges, tears, and fading, keeping your branding crisp and professional-looking even after considerable wear and tear. Although they tend to be pricier upfront, the durability often justifies the investment by reducing the need for replacements and protecting your product’s presentation in challenging environments.
Helpful Tips When Choosing Between Paper and Waterproof Labels
- Consider the environment: Is your product going to be exposed to rain, steam, or refrigeration? Waterproof labels are better suited for these harsh conditions and will keep your branding intact.
- Think about the product surface: If you’re labeling curved bottles, containers with textured surfaces, or packaging that might flex, a more flexible and tough label material is necessary to avoid cracking or peeling.
- Match your branding: Paper labels often evoke a natural, eco-friendly vibe that resonates with certain audiences, while waterproof labels typically have a sleeker, more contemporary look that might align better with modern or luxury brands.
- Check your budget: Paper labels usually cost less upfront, but waterproof labels can save money over time by avoiding the hassle and cost of re-labeling or handling customer complaints.
- Ask about finishes: Applying lamination or varnishes to paper labels can enhance durability and elevate the appearance, but these add-ons might also affect the feel and cost.
- Proof your design: Keep in mind that colors can behave quite differently on paper compared to synthetic stocks, so always request a sample or proof before committing to a large print run.
A Quick Case Example: Jam Jar Labels
Here’s a story from a small artisan jam maker we recently worked with. They were torn between using paper or waterproof labels. Their jams are often gifted and stored in kitchens where moisture and sticky fingers are par for the course.
Initially, they picked uncoated paper labels to capture a rustic, homemade feel. But after a few batches, they started seeing the labels peel and smudge, which didn’t sit well with customers or the brand image.
We recommended switching to matte waterproof polypropylene labels with a soft-touch finish—something that would hold up better but still keep that tactile, natural vibe. The new labels stayed pristine despite kitchen conditions, preserved the rustic charm, and customers noticed the improved quality. Fewer complaints followed, which was a relief for the maker.
This example highlights how testing label materials in real-world conditions can reveal what truly suits your product’s use and customer expectations.
Wrapping Up: Your Label Choice Made Easier
There isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer when it comes to choosing between paper and waterproof labels. But understanding the pros and cons can clear the fog quite a bit. Paper labels tend to fit dry, indoor products with a natural, budget-conscious appeal. Waterproof labels shine where durability and moisture resistance are critical.
Having printed hundreds of label runs across the UK—from tiny batches for local artisans to large-scale productions—we know a thing or two about getting it right. We can help you navigate stock choices, finishes, and formats to make sure your labels not only look great but last as long as they need to.
Unsure which label type fits your project best? You can always email us your artwork for a quick, free check. We’re also happy to advise on how to prepare your files for the best print results, so you avoid any surprises.
Updated on 23 December 2025
Ready to print? Contact Newstyle Print for a fast quote today.
Call 01572 771377 or email hello@newstyleprint.co.uk
Get a quote »
